Europe's 174 Billion Euro Gap: Must Private Investors Rescue Digital Networks?

Contents

Europe dreams of the digital decade, but the reality on construction sites and in the balance sheets of network operators is sobering. By 2030, the EU wants to guarantee gigabit connections for every household and comprehensive 5G coverage. However, a gap exists between these political ambitions and economic implementation: According to an analysis of the European telecommunications market by the consulting firm Kearney, at least 174 billion euros in additional investments are missing to achieve the set goals. If this gap is not closed, around 45 million EU citizens could remain without adequate network connectivity by the end of the decade.

What is particularly bitter for Germany as a location is its performance in the "European Telecom Health Index," which is part of the study for the first time. The continent's largest economy ranks only 15th out of 20 countries surveyed in terms of the sector's well-being. This places the Federal Republic in the lower third, far behind digital pioneers such as Norway, Sweden, or Portugal. Germany achieves only 64 out of a possible 100 points.

This finding confirms earlier relevant results. According to Kearney, it harbors significant risks for future competitiveness. This is because the countries in the lower half of the index together account for around 70 percent of the European population and almost two-thirds of the economic output.

Deceptive Stability of the German Market

According to the study, the core problem of the industry is self-inflicted and systemic. Established telecommunications providers are financially at their limit, as high debt burdens and moderate returns leave them with little room for major upfront investments. Even the industry association Connect Europe admits that the sector is too weak to shoulder the burden alone. In Germany, a paradoxical picture emerges: While operators still achieve solid returns on capital of around ten percent, this success is largely based on the high utilization of outdated copper and coaxial networks.

Fiber optic now reaches about half of households in Germany. However, the connection rate is just over 25 percent. Many customers continue to use the existing old infrastructure, which only allows returns from new investments to flow in slowly. At the same time, dissatisfaction is growing: in markets with poorer performance like Germany, customers express a greater willingness to switch and more frequently demand better service quality and more stable networks than in the top nations.

AI Boom Fuels Data Hunger

Meanwhile, technological development continues. According to the analysis, internet traffic in Europe has almost ninefold between 2014 and 2022 and is growing by another 20 to 25 percent annually. The actual market-changing factor is Artificial Intelligence (AI), the adoption of which is expected to triple the demand for data center capacities by 2030. Companies need significantly more cloud capacities and computing power to keep pace with global developments.

Based solely on increased AI use, other consultants such as Goldman Sachs predict a 165 percent increase in electricity demand in data centers by 2030. This development makes it clear that digital infrastructure – fiber optics, 5G, and edge nodes for computing power at the ends of the networks – is no longer a niche topic, according to Kearney. It forms the foundation for modern innovation, communication, and Europe's sovereignty. The constitution of the economy depends directly on this basis.

Private Equity as the "Hero" of the Networks

In this predicament, according to the authors, the time has come for private equity firms and specialized infrastructure funds, which are developing into "unsung heroes" of the digital transformation. When governments and traditional network operators reach their limits, such private market players still have sufficiently deep pockets: Global assets under management in private infrastructure investments have quadrupled in the past decade to a record sum of 1.4 trillion US dollars. Investors are currently attracted primarily by stable, utility-like cash flows and the enormous upside potential through AI and the cloud.

Initial major transactions in Europe underscore the trend. Deutsche Telekom sold 51 percent of its mobile tower division for 10.7 billion euros to Brookfield and DigitalBridge to reduce debt and finance 5G investments. Vodafone sold shares in Vantage Towers to KKR and GIP. In the fiber optic sector as well, investors such as Antin or KKR are on the verge of accelerating rollouts in underserved areas. Private capital is now critical for Europe to host more of its own data and reduce dependence on US hyperscalers.

Fragmentation as an Investment Brake

The study illustrates that Europe urgently needs to rethink its market structures. While in the USA and China, only about three major providers dominate the market and account for over 97 percent of revenue, the European sector is very fragmented with 90 mobile operators alone. In Germany, four providers continue to compete for market share. Markets with three operators achieved higher profit margins and better returns on capital on average.

Kearney therefore advises promoting consolidation. "Buy-and-build strategies," for example, could help merge smaller players into efficient platforms. This, in turn, could lead to economies of scale for regional fiber optic providers or data centers, enabling lower unit costs and more innovation. The separation into pure infrastructure and service companies is also seen as a logical step to attract specialized investors.

Risks of Private Equity

For private money to flow permanently into European networks, the consultants conclude, politics must change the framework conditions. Investors need planning security: it must be clear what prices they can charge for network usage and how the allocation of radio frequencies will proceed in the long term. Furthermore, too much bureaucracy is hindering progress. Permits for new fiber optic lines or data centers must be issued much faster – for example, through an "express lane" for digital construction projects. Financial incentives such as tax credits could also help secure the interest of private investors.

The call for more private equity is not without risk. Critics point out that financial investors often focus on short-term profit maximization and a quick profitable resale. This does not always align with the state's interest in a permanent, affordable basic supply for all citizens. Furthermore, there is a risk that the technical overall responsibility of traditional providers will be eroded by the outsourcing of networks.

(akn)