Zahlen, bitte! 154 nominations and still no Nobel Prize in Literature

Ramón Menéndez Pidal was nominated for the Nobel Prize in Literature a total of 154 times. This set a remarkable and little-known record.

listen Print view
6 min. read
By
  • Detlef Borchers
Contents

If you believe the Guinness Book of Records, it is the book that is stolen most from public libraries. The universal chronicle of records also lists many facts about books. The smallest book, the largest book, the heaviest, and the most expensive – all can be found in the book.

Zahlen, bitte!
Bitte Zahlen

In this section, we present amazing, impressive, informative and funny figures ("Zahlen") from the fields of IT, science, art, business, politics and, of course, mathematics every Tuesday. The wordplay "Zahlen, bitte!" for a section about numbers is based on the ambiguity of the German word "Zahlen." On one hand, "Zahlen" can be understood as a noun in the sense of digits and numerical values, which fits the theme of the section. On the other hand, the phrase "Zahlen, bitte!" is reminiscent of a waiter's request in a restaurant or bar when they are asked to bring the bill. Through this association, the section acquires a playful and slightly humorous undertone that catches the readers' attention and makes them curious about the presented numbers and facts.

The quirky record for the highest number of signed books is also noted: Spaniard Eloy Moreno, a former computer scientist, managed to sign 11,088 books with his name in 12 hours.

However, Ramón Menéndez Pidal, his compatriot, not only lacks the Nobel Prize in Literature despite 154 nominations but also an entry for it in the record almanac. Negative records are simply not the forte of fact-checkers.

Yet, Pidal's record of 154 nominations may already have been broken. To preserve peace in the world of literature and science, archives are only opened after 50 years.

The Spanish philologist and historian Ramón Menéndez Pidal (* March 13, 1869, La Coruña, Spain; † November 14, 1968 in Madrid) is seen here in 1964, bearded, at Madrid Airport.

(Image: Ibera Airlines, CC BY 2.0)

Therefore, we do not know how nominations and votes were cast in 2016 when Bob Dylan received the Nobel Prize in Literature. This caused considerable discussion. However, we do know which author nominated himself. In 1903, the writer Godfrey Sweven was nominated for his science fiction epic “Limanora: The Island of Progress.” On the island of Limanora, people can fly, sleep on electric beds that implant knowledge during dreams (the science is called somnology), and generally improve themselves eugenically. Research revealed that the nomination came from New Zealand literary professor John Macmillan Brown, who published his books under the pseudonym Godfrey Sweven.

For the Nobel Prize in Literature, previous laureates, chairpersons of national and international writers' associations, and members of the Nobel Committee are eligible to nominate. Thus, Gerhart Hauptmann nominated Thomas Mann, and Mann nominated Hermann Hesse. When Sinclair Lewis became the first American to surprisingly receive the Nobel Prize in 1930, he was nominated by committee member Henrick Schück because he writes in a new language, “American.” Before this, Lewis should have received the Pulitzer Prize, but he rejected it with a sweeping critique of belletristic literature and the portrayal of a perfect America. Two years later, the international left tried to help his spiritual cousin, Upton Sinclair, win the Nobel Prize with 800 votes. That did not work out.

The Swiss Carl Spitteler fared better with his epic “Olympic Spring,” written in 1905, which updated Greek mythology in 20,000 verses. The gods deploy automatons to fight against humans. What the humans had to endure was recorded by a type of data processing system with hammers on metal rollers. For his verse epic, Spitteler, nominated since 1915, finally received the literature prize for 1919 (awarded in 1920), likely also because he advocated for reconciliation in 1914.

Sometimes there were actual campaigns for the nomination of candidates. Thus, 412 German professors petitioned for the writer Arno Holz in 1929.

While a division of the Nobel Prize is common in scientific categories like medicine and physics, it is a very rare exception for the Nobel Prize in literature. This happened for the second time in 1974, when Swedes Eyvind Johnson and Harry Martinson shared the prize. Martinson was explicitly honored for his verse epic Aniara. Aniara is a spaceship on its way to Mars because Earth is destroyed by pollution and wars. During an evasive maneuver with an asteroid, Aniara becomes disabled. The 8,000 Earth migrants drifting into space are cared for and comforted by a computer named Mima. In the end, the artificial intelligence succumbs to the passengers' grief, and the computer crashes.

A Nobel Prize nomination is not necessarily a guarantee of winning a Nobel Prize, as shown by the coin depicted here for Jimmy Carter

(Image: ArtemisiaGentileschiFan, CC0)

Who doesn't feel reminded of Physics Nobel laureate Geoffrey Hinton, who suggested that when training AI systems, particular attention should be paid to the maternal instincts that must be instilled in the machines?

Videos by heise

Before Martinson, his compatriot Hannes Alfvén received a Nobel Prize in 1970, also for physics. He is considered the founder of magnetohydrodynamics. Under the pseudonym Olof Johannesson, Alfvén had “The Saga of the Great Computer: A Retrospective from the Future,” published in 1966. “The narrative depicts the path to world domination by thinking machines and the internet in three stages: teletotal (computer network), minitotal (network with mobile devices), and neurototal (chips in the brain).” In this futuristic book, people live in the “Perfect People's Democracy,” where computers make all decisions, and people are “free” because they can turn off their devices at any time. Until someone discovers that the chips are secretly turning them back on.

Briton Kazuo Ishiguro received the Nobel Prize in Literature in 2017 for the bleak work “Never Let Me Go.” In it, human clones serve as organ replacement depots. After winning the prize, Ishiguro decided to write an optimistic children's book. The result was “Klara and the Sun,” in which Klara, an artificial intelligence powered by solar energy, becomes a friend to the growing, often ill Josie and helps her. Josie recovers and goes to college, while Klara ends up in the junkyard.
Even machines are ephemeral – like unheard Nobel Prize nominations.

(mho)

Don't miss any news – follow us on Facebook, LinkedIn or Mastodon.

This article was originally published in German. It was translated with technical assistance and editorially reviewed before publication.